Richard Kone lit up the round while the model’s cleanest win came from William Lankshear
Six calls landed and six did not, which is tidy only in the accountant’s sense. QPR’s 5-0 burst, Middlesbrough’s 5-1 away win at Bolton, and Wolves’ narrow home victory were the better reads; Charlton, Lincoln, Stoke and West Ham were where the numbers got mugged by events.
The round split neatly between the calls that held and the ones that went wandering. Fipster found enough of the right winners to keep the week respectable, but the misses were not cosmetic. Charlton, Lincoln, Stoke City and West Ham all went against the grain in different ways, and each one exposed a different habit: too much faith in a tight home edge, too much trust in a scoring streak, or too much comfort with a scoreline that looked neat on paper. The good news is that the model still found several of the right outcomes. The less good news is that football had no interest in being neat about it.
William Lankshear was the read that held up best
The cleanest hit was Middlesbrough’s 5-1 win at Bolton. Fipster called an away win and named William Lankshear among the scorers; he delivered twice and finished as one of the standout performers. That matters because it was not just a lucky nod at a busy attack. The pre-match case leaned on Middlesbrough’s scoring power and Lankshear’s recent output, and both survived contact with the afternoon. A model can be forgiven for missing the exact margin if it has at least identified who is most likely to do damage. Here, it did exactly that with William Lankshear.
Charlton-Norwich was where the shortlist got too tidy
The miss that says most about the round is Charlton’s 1-3 defeat to Norwich. Fipster backed a narrow home win and did not call any scorers there, which left no room for Charlie Lee-Kelman, Edmond-Paris Maghoma or Mathias Damm Kvistgaarden to spoil the party. The model over-weighted Charlton’s home shape and under-read Norwich’s ability to produce goals from players outside any obvious shortlist. That is usually how these errors happen: not through wild fantasy, but through assuming control will turn into control of the scoreline. It did not. Norwich scored first through Edmond-Paris Maghoma, then let Mathias Damm Kvistgaarden take over from there.
Richard Kone took centre stage; others arrived uninvited
The loudest individual story belonged to Richard Kone at QPR. Fipster had no scorer call there, yet Richard Kone scored three times and Jordan James Dunne added two more in a 5-0 win over Swansea. That is exactly the sort of game that punishes caution: once one player starts finishing everything in sight, every pre-match theory about balance looks rather dainty. Jordan James Dunne also mattered because he turned a comfortable lead into something far more emphatic than Fipster had imagined. Elsewhere, Mikkel Riis Ladefoged stood out for Lincoln with two goals against Burnley, while Thomas Waddingham scored late for Portsmouth after Fipster had leaned on other names entirely.
Adam Armstrong was another useful reminder that one accurate call can still be lonely work when several matches go sideways around it. He scored Wolves’ only goal in a 1-0 win over Watford after Fipster had looked elsewhere for Wolves’ threat. That was a proper hit on outcome even if it was not built on a named scorer call. At the other end of the scale sat West Ham-Southampton: Fipster expected control from West Ham, but Southampton got goals from Kuryu Matsuki, Jordan James Bree and Lewis Dobbin before Tomáš Souček made it close at the end. Daniel Peretz’s big rating for Southampton tells its own story too; sometimes a keeper does not just keep you alive, he changes what everyone else thinks is possible.
Who decided the round
Called by Fipster pre-match vs who actually scoredWilliam Lankshear
Middlesbrough
2goalsCalledRichard Kone
QPR
3goalsUnforeseenJames Dunne
QPR
2goalsUnforeseenAndri Guðjohnsen
Blackburn
2goalsUnforeseenYousef Salech
Cardiff
2goalsUnforeseenMikkel Riis Ladefoged
Lincoln
2goalsUnforeseenKyle Walker-Peters
West Ham
1goalUnforeseenTomáš Souček
West Ham
1goalUnforeseen