West Brom were the cleanest read, but the round belonged to the names Fipster left out
One exact call landed cleanly in West Brom’s 3-0 over Millwall, yet the wider story was less tidy: several of the round’s decisive goals came from players outside the pre-match shortlist, and a few of the model’s favourite scorers never got near the net.
West Brom gave the model its one proper clean hit
The best call was West Brom to beat Millwall, and it did not need any rescue act. The model liked the home side’s scoring spine, and that part of the read held up neatly: Isaac Price scored, Jayson Molumby added one of his own, and West Brom finished with the sort of control that makes a prediction look sensible rather than lucky. The useful bit here was not just the result, but the shape of it. Fipster had leaned on West Brom’s midfield threat, and that is exactly where the game turned.
The miss that says most about this round came at Derby
If one forecast shows where the model overreached, it is Derby against Bolton. Fipster backed Bolton’s attacking names — Samuel Dalby, Bobby Clark, Samuel Szmodics and Lars-Jørgen Salvesen — but none of them scored. Instead, Ruben Rodrigues opened for Bolton before Derby took over through Ryan Nyambe, Jack Robinson and Rhian Brewster. That is a cleaner lesson than any scoreline alone: the model trusted Bolton’s usual goal sources too much and did not give enough weight to Derby finding answers from elsewhere. The late winner-take-all feel of it was not in the forecast at all.
The round’s loudest performers were often the ones Fipster had already circled — or missed entirely
There were some tidy individual wins for the shortlist. Andri Guðjohnsen and Oladapo Afolayan both scored for Blackburn after being named before kick-off, which is exactly what a decent player call should do: point to danger before anyone has actually done anything dangerous. Richard Kone did similar work for QPR, scoring early after being flagged pre-match, even if QPR then had to rely on Glen Adjei Kamara to finish the job. Jack McGlynn and Benjamin Wilmot also rewarded Stoke backers by scoring in Portsmouth.
But this round also belonged to players Fipster did not name first time around. Jay Stansfield scored twice for Birmingham without being on the shortlist. Yousef Salech scored twice for Cardiff from nowhere as far as the pre-match calls were concerned. Joël Ramzan Piroe decided Blackburn’s game for West Ham after being left out too. Add in Harry Darling and Andre Chance Brooks for Norwich, plus Jayson Molumby and Felix Horn Myhre for West Brom, and you get a clear pattern: plenty of decisive moments came from outside the model’s chosen lane.
What this round asks for next
The useful response is not caution for its own sake. West Brom showed that when Fipster has a strong read on structure and scorer involvement, it can land properly. The misses came when familiar attacking names were treated as if they would naturally own every game they touched. They do not always oblige; football has manners like that only occasionally. Next time out, the job is to keep trusting strong team reads while leaving more room for lesser-seen scorers to walk into frame.
Who decided the round
Called by Fipster pre-match vs who actually scoredOladapo Afolayan
Blackburn
1goalCalledBenjamin Wilmot
Stoke City
1goalCalledEdmond-Paris Maghoma
Norwich
1goalCalledAndri Guðjohnsen
Blackburn
1goalCalledJack McGlynn
Stoke City
1goalCalledJay Stansfield
Birmingham
2goalsUnforeseenYousef Salech
Cardiff
2goalsUnforeseenJoël Ramzan Piroe
West Ham
1goalUnforeseen